Geoffrey Sigalet: What’s at stake in the fight over the notwithstanding clause

Geoffrey Sigalet: What’s at stake in the fight over the notwithstanding clause

Constitutional law is often seen as the domain of courts and legal scholars, but one provision—the notwithstanding clause—has become a flashpoint in Canada’s ongoing debate over the balance of power between legislatures and the judiciary.

Once a political safety valve that sealed the deal for the Charter of Rights and Freedoms in 1982, section 33 is now at the center of a national conversation about who should have the final say on fundamental rights.

To unpack the history and stakes of this debate, Professor Geof Sigalet joins Peter Copeland to explain how the notwithstanding clause was born out of provincial insistence on preserving democratic self-government, and how its use has evolved in response to rising judicial activism and federal-provincial tensions.

Sigalet delves into the recent controversies surrounding Quebec’s Bill 21 and the federal government’s intervention, highlighting the clause’s role as both a shield for provincial autonomy and a lightning rod for national debate.

As courts and governments clash over the limits of the notwithstanding clause, the future of Canada’s constitutional balance hangs in the balance.

Det här avsnittet är hämtat från ett öppet RSS-flöde och publiceras inte av Podme. Det kan innehålla reklam.

Avsnitt(140)

Étienne-Alexandre Beauregard: Making the case for the common good

Étienne-Alexandre Beauregard: Making the case for the common good

Western societies face a growing crisis with a gradual waning of trust, social cohesion, and shared norms. But is something deeper happening to the cultural foundations that make free societies possib...

10 Sep 1h 10min

Eric Kaufmann: How diversity requirements reduced productivity for Canada's research chairs

Eric Kaufmann: How diversity requirements reduced productivity for Canada's research chairs

Critics of DEI have long warned that demographic-based hiring requirements can come at the expense of merit and academic excellence. In a recent MLI paper, The equity excellence trade-off: A study of ...

4 Sep 57min

Sylvain Charlebois: Canada's dairy industry in decline

Sylvain Charlebois: Canada's dairy industry in decline

Canada's dairy industry is one of the most protected sectors of the Canadian economy. But is that protection holding the industry back?While Canada's dairy sector has long benefited from policies desi...

21 Aug 52min

Lt.-Col. Joel Maley: Deterrence is cheaper than defence

Lt.-Col. Joel Maley: Deterrence is cheaper than defence

Latvia is home to Canada's largest overseas military deployment, with more than 2,000 members of the Canadian Armed Forces serving on NATO's eastern flank.Why are Canadians there? Why should Canadians...

14 Aug 50min

Rainer Knopff and Ted Morton: Canadian judges ran amok with the Charter

Rainer Knopff and Ted Morton: Canadian judges ran amok with the Charter

Special episode: Peter Copeland, acting director of domestic policy at MLI, sat down last month with eminent Canadian political scientists Rainer Knopff and Ted Morton. 25 years ago Morton and Knopff'...

6 Aug 1h 2min

Carl Trueman: Euthanasia, transgenderism, and transgression

Carl Trueman: Euthanasia, transgenderism, and transgression

By almost every material measure life has become safer, richer, and more convenient... so why do many people seem more anxious, lonely, and unhappy?We often explain this malaise in economic or psychol...

30 Juli 1h 4min

Garry Clement: Foreign actors see Canada as the lane of least resistance

Garry Clement: Foreign actors see Canada as the lane of least resistance

For years Canada seemed to be the more peaceful part of North America. But that narrative is changing.Recently a Toronto police officer was shot while investigating a series of shootings in the city, ...

23 Juli 51min

Rob Henderson: Stigma and expectations will make your life better

Rob Henderson: Stigma and expectations will make your life better

For young men, there used to be “a ton of societal pressure on you to make something of yourself.” That’s one of many positive culture norms that we’ve now lost, says author Rob Henderson.Today, “some...

16 Juli 1h 1min

Populärt inom Politik & nyheter

aftonbladet-krim
svenska-fall
p3-krim
fordomspodden
rss-krimstad
politiken
en-runda-till
flashback-forever
aftonbladet-daily
rss-vad-fan-hande
rss-krimreportrarna
rss-sanning-konsekvens
rss-flodet
svd-ledarredaktionen
motiv
rss-frandfors-horna
omni-podd
rss-expressen-dok
rss-utopia-2
spar