I Think Not!

18-year-old Samantha Bonnell and her boyfriend Chris were selling magazines (MAGAZINES?) door to door with a company that took them to cities across the country. One night, Samantha went out with new friends in a strange city and never came back. It would take over a year and an unimaginable amount of internet sleuthing from Samantha's mother to find out what happened. Hey, DBs!  A message from the future here! Obsessed with: Disappeared transformed into I Think Not! after we finished recapping all the episodes of Disappeared - and our social media did, too! Follow us @ithinknotpod on Twitter, Instagram and TikTok and check out our website at www.ithinknotpod.com!

10 Feb 202145min

Sherrill Levett, her daughter Suzie Streeter,  and Stacy McCall, mysteriously vanished on Sunday, June 7, 1992—just hours after attending the girls’ high school graduation. All of their personal belongings, including cars and purses, were left behind. There were no signs of a struggle, except a broken porch light globe; there was also a message on the answering machine that police believe might have provided a clue about the disappearances, but it was inadvertently erased. It’s one of the most famous—and baffling—missing persons cases of our time. And we have LOTS to say about it! Hey, DBs!  A message from the future here! Obsessed with: Disappeared transformed into I Think Not! after we finished recapping all the episodes of Disappeared - and our social media did, too! Follow us @ithinknotpod on Twitter, Instagram and TikTok and check out our website at www.ithinknotpod.com!

3 Feb 202149min

On May 15, 2005, Ray Gricar took the day off. At 11:30 am he called his girlfriend at work and told her he wouldn’t be home until late afternoon—he was going on a drive in the back roads of Amish Country in Pennsylvania. Nobody has ever seen or heard from him again. What happened? Did he walk out of his life? Did he meet with foul play? Where. The hell. Is Ray? Hey, DBs!  A message from the future here! Obsessed with: Disappeared transformed into I Think Not! after we finished recapping all the episodes of Disappeared - and our social media did, too! Follow us @ithinknotpod on Twitter, Instagram and TikTok and check out our website at www.ithinknotpod.com!

27 Jan 202150min

Get this episode ad-free, and all of our episodes ad-free, HERE! On March 13, 2000, 23-year-old Leah Roberts packed her car, withdrew $3000 in cash from the bank, and hit the road in her Jeep Cherokee. Though she was close with her family and friends, she didn’t tell anyone she was leaving on a cross country journey. 5 days later, her car was found wrecked and abandoned 3000 miles from home in a ravine in Bellingham, Washington. There was no sign of Leah at the crash site and nobody has seen or heard from her since. What happened? WHERE. THE HELL. IS LEAH? Hey, DBs!  A message from the future here! Obsessed with: Disappeared transformed into I Think Not! after we finished recapping all the episodes of Disappeared - and our social media did, too! Follow us @ithinknotpod on Twitter, Instagram and TikTok and check out our website at www.ithinknotpod.com!

20 Jan 202150min

In the early morning hours of August 23, 2009, 29-year-old Toni Sharpless and her friend (THE DOWNEST BITCH OF ALL TIME) Crystal Johns left a party in the suburbs of Philadelphia. Toni was drunk—way too drunk to drive—and upset. Toni forced Crystal out of her car and then drove off into the night. Nobody ever saw her again. What happened? Where is Toni? Hey, DBs!  A message from the future here! Obsessed with: Disappeared transformed into I Think Not! after we finished recapping all the episodes of Disappeared - and our social media did, too! Follow us @ithinknotpod on Twitter, Instagram and TikTok and check out our website at www.ithinknotpod.com!

13 Jan 202149min

28-year-old Jeremy Alex had a carefree approach to life—He ‘worked to live rather than lived to work.’ His friends and girlfriend describe him as easy going and fun to be around. But suddenly there’s a dramatic change: the people around him notice that He’s paranoid, aggressive, and acting erratically. He starts telling people that bad guys are after him. And then, suddenly, he vanishes. His friends and family search for days, but come up with nothing. And it’s not until four years later that significant clue emerges. So, WHERE. THE HELL. IS JEREMY? Hey, DBs!  A message from the future here! Obsessed with: Disappeared transformed into I Think Not! after we finished recapping all the episodes of Disappeared - and our social media did, too! Follow us @ithinknotpod on Twitter, Instagram and TikTok and check out our website at www.ithinknotpod.com!

6 Jan 202148min

In this interview, Rosa give us new information on her sister's case, shares new evidence that she uncovered herself, and tells us what she think happened to her sister.  Hey, DBs!  A message from the future here! Obsessed with: Disappeared transformed into I Think Not! after we finished recapping all the episodes of Disappeared - and our social media did, too! Follow us @ithinknotpod on Twitter, Instagram and TikTok and check out our website at www.ithinknotpod.com!

30 Dec 202021min

Roxanne Paltauf vanished on July 7, 2006. She and her boyfriend had been staying at a Budget Inn in a rough section of Austin, Texas. According to the boyfriend, he and Roxanne got into a fight at about 8:30 pm and she stormed off, never to be seen again. But His story has holes and is impossible to verify. And when Roxanne's ID is found in the possession of another known sexual offender, her family fears the worst. WHERE. THE HELL. IS ROXANNE? Hey, DBs!  A message from the future here! Obsessed with: Disappeared transformed into I Think Not! after we finished recapping all the episodes of Disappeared - and our social media did, too! Follow us @ithinknotpod on Twitter, Instagram and TikTok and check out our website at www.ithinknotpod.com!

30 Dec 202048min