Evidence Locker | Natalia Grace
The three mustaches open up the evidence locker once again to bring you a very special episode featuring the amazingly talented Clayne Crawford. Clayne has starred in films such as A Walk to Remember ...
27 Nov 20251h 23min
96 | The Evidence Locker | Ellen Rae Greenberg
You asked for it, and the three mustaches listened. This week, we're cracking open the Evidence Locker and bringing you an previously unreleased episode! On a cold, winter night in 2011, 28-year-old E...
20 Nov 20251h 45min
95 | Emily Noble | Suicide Surrounds Them
The three mustaches take a journey to the greatest state in America to cover the tragic case of Emily Noble. In May of 2020, in Westerville, Ohio, police received a report of a woman that was possibly...
13 Nov 20252h 19min
94 | Kristil Krug | Stalk a Mile in My Shoes
The three mustaches travel to Colorado to cover the case of Kristil Krug and her noodly-armed husband, Daniel. When Kristil rejects the advances of a former boyfriend, she soon learns that her old fla...
6 Nov 20252h 13min
93 | Lois Riess | The Gambling Granny
The three mustaches grab their lucky four-leaf clovers to cover the case of Losing Streak Lois. This poor woman just couldn’t seem to catch a break. First her husband gets gunned down in their own hom...
30 Okt 20252h 20min
92 | Donna Adelson | All in the Family
The three mustaches get together to tackle a convoluted, murder-for-hire case out of Tallahassee, Florida. When 41-year-old law professor, Dan Markel, is brutally gunned down in his driveway by two me...
23 Okt 20252h 33min
91 | Donna Scrivo | Donna Dearest
The three mustaches put on some leathers and hop into their war rig to tackle a case from the post-apocalyptic wasteland known as Detroit. When Donna Scrivo’s 32-year-old son, Ramsay, went missing in ...
16 Okt 20251h 28min
90 | Robert Eugene Brashers | Yogurt Shop Justice
The three mustaches convene to discuss a shocking breakthrough in a number of decades-old cold cases. After nearly 40 years, the monster responsible for the horrific Yogurt Shop Murders has finally be...
9 Okt 20252h 2min
