88 | Dylan Rounds | Light in the Ariats
The three mustaches take another trip to the barren deserts of Utah to investigate the disappearance of Dylan Rounds. When the 19-year-old, aspiring farmer went missing from his homestead in 2022, inv...
25 Sep 20251h 45min
87 | Susan Powell | Missing or Murdered?
The mustache mafia welcomes a new member for a deep dive into the disappearance of Susan Powell. After the mother of two went missing in 2009, authorities spent years trying to figure out who was resp...
17 Sep 20252h 16min
86 | Issei Sagawa | Cannibal 2: Electric Boogaloo
The three mustaches travel to the far east to continue their deep dive into the mind of the Kobe cannibal, Issei Sagawa. In this episode we will learn that it is not only possible to get away with kil...
11 Sep 20251h 46min
85 | Issei Sagawa | Kobe Cannibal
The original three mustaches reunite to read select passages from some classic literature written by a creepy little goblin named Issei Sagawa. We’ve covered some real sickos in the past, but this guy...
4 Sep 20251h 10min
84 | Kathryn Restelli | American Fork Fiasco
The three mustaches put on their magic underwear and head to American Fork, Utah to cover the death of Matthew Restelli. When investigators arrive at the home of Tracy Grist to investigate an alleged ...
28 Aug 20251h 45min
83 | Ashley Reeves | Missing In Millstadt
The three mustaches head to Illinois to defend their title as the undisputed world champions of true crime. When 17-year-old Ashley Reeves disappears on her way to a job interview, some of the best de...
21 Aug 20251h 14min
82 | Janet Overton | Tainted Love
The three mustaches take a trip to Southern California to solve the mysterious death of 46-year-old Janet Overton. After suffering from a mysterious illness for over two years, Janet suddenly collapse...
13 Aug 20251h 24min
81 | Kayla Giles | License to Love
The three mustaches set out to prove the innocence of the future Mrs Coop, Kayla Giles. Since 2018, Kayla has been fighting a murder charge after allegedly killing her estranged ex-husband in self def...
7 Aug 20252h 13min
