It's the Mystery for Me (A True Crime Podcast)

Tynesha Stewart was an honors student throughout high school and graduated in the top 3% of her class. Talk about black excellence! Unsurprisingly, she had scholarship offers to multiple colleges and ultimately decided to attend Texas A&M University, which was only 2 hours away. Tynesha was on the verge of completing her second semester in college when tragedy struck. Law enforcement describes this case as one of the most gruesome ones they've seen in their careers. Who ...

30 Jan 202446min

At 20, Andreen McDonald, a Jamaican native, married Andre McDonald, a captain in the Air Force, and moved to San Antonio, Texas to begin their lives together. By 22, she had built an assisted living business. By 29, that business had made her a millionaire. Everything in her life was absolutely fabulous: she was now a mom to a beautiful daughter, had a loving husband and tons of support from her family and friends. By all accounts, she was healthy and seemingly happy....

23 Jan 202449min

Angela Bledsoe had experienced much success as a financial analyst in her 20’s, which continued to grow through the years. By 2018, Angela, 44, was also a mother to six-year-old Alana and living in a beautiful home in Montclair, NJ, with her longtime partner and father of her child, James Ray. All seemed to be going well for this thriving family, until the fateful day of October 22, 2018. But that was just the tip of the iceberg. For a list of sources from toda...

9 Jan 20241h

In 2005, LaVena Johnson, 19, was in the midst of an active tour in Iraq. Just two years prior, she had decided to follow in her father’s footsteps by enlisting in the U.S. army—a dream that became her own. Flash forward to July 2005, LaVena had only been deployed for six weeks in Iraq when things suddenly took a turn. What came next were a series of conflicting stories and details about her time in the U.S. army. So, will the truth be revealed? For a list of sources from today's...

2 Jan 202458min

Tamika Huston, 24, had a promising future ahead of her. In the summer of 2004, she had just completed another semester of nursing school when she suddenly goes off the radar. Tamika’s family and friends assumed she had taken a spontaneous trip to kick off the summer. But they knew something wasn’t right when Tamika’s beloved dog Macy was found left behind in her home. So, where did Tamika go off to? For a list of sources from today's episode and pictures, please visit www.itsthemystery...

7 Nov 20231h 2min

On January 7, 2016, Tyarra Williams, 19, had just completed her first day of college classes and was looking forward to picking up her textbooks and school supplies the following day. This was a big deal for Tyarra, who decided to pursue a career in early childhood development. But the next day came and went without a single word from Tyarra. So, what changed in the matter of a day? For a list of sources from today's episode and pictures, please visit www.itsthemysteryform...

17 Okt 202339min

On New Years Eve of 2009, Mikarah Sanders, 15, had planned to ring in the new year with her boyfriend and some friends. But a few hours before the clock struck 12, shots were suddenly fired. Mikarah’s family are stunned by the news. Mikarah is kindhearted and wise beyond her years. So, who would want to hurt Mikarah or was it simply a case of wrong place, wrong time? For a list of sources from today's episode and pictures, please visit www.itsthemysteryforme.com/episodes/mikarah-sander...

10 Okt 20231h 2min

Latrese Curtis, 21, was on her way home to her husband. But while awaiting her arrival, he had fallen asleep. In the morning, Latrese had still not returned home. Panic soon set in as her family tried desperately to find her. What they uncovered was something completely unexpected. So, what really happened to Latrese? For a list of sources from today's episode and pictures, please visit www.itsthemysteryforme.com/episodes/latrese-curtis Attorney Benjamin Crump's Instagram post highlig...

3 Okt 202359min